Toronto's beloved neighbourhood pie bakery — Wanda's Pie in the Sky has been making hand-crafted fruit pies, cream pies, tarts, and squares in Kensington Market since the 1990s. The butter crust is made from scratch daily, the fillings are seasonal and real, and the price is the kind of honest that bakeries used to be before the gourmet boom.
Neighbourhood: Kensington Market · Address: 287 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON · Hours: Mon–Fri 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM | Sat 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM | Sun 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM · Price Range: $ · Phone: (416) 236-7585
Wanda's Pie in the Sky is where you can score a seriously good slice of fruit or cream pie without emptying your wallet, right in the heart of Kensington Market. It's perfect for anyone craving homemade desserts that haven't gone 'gourmet' in price or attitude.
Few bakeries in Toronto still make their own butter crusts daily and actually use real, seasonal fruit for fillings—Wanda's does both. The old-school pricing is a rarity anywhere downtown, and you can grab a slice, a whole pie, or a square to go, without any fuss. Plus, it's one of the few spots where you can actually watch pies being assembled out in the open kitchen.
Wanda’s Pie in the Sky is exactly the kind of Toronto bakery that feels reassuring the second you walk in: not polished to the point of sterility, not trying to dazzle you with a twelve-step pastry program, just steady, familiar, and very good at the things it chooses to do. It’s been in Kensington Market long enough that plenty of locals have a personal relationship with it — the kind that starts with “we used to get birthday pies there when we were kids” and ends with “I still stop in whenever I’m in the neighbourhood.” That’s really the best way to understand Wanda’s. It’s not a novelty stop. It’s a dependable neighbourhood bakery that has stayed focused on butter crust, seasonal fruit, proper fillings, and prices that still feel sane in a city where dessert can easily turn into a luxury item.
The first thing you notice is the smell. There’s a warm, buttery sweetness in the air, but it’s not cloying or overworked. If they’ve got fruit pies out, there’s that particular baked-fruit aroma that tells you the fillings are made from actual fruit, not a generic syrupy base that tastes the same in January and August. In the morning, the place can feel calm and almost sleepy, with the pie cases looking full and orderly, the sort of setup that makes you want to buy breakfast and dessert at the same time. By late morning and into the afternoon, the energy picks up. Kensington brings in a mix of regulars, people wandering the neighbourhood with coffee, families, students, and visitors who’ve done their research and know this is one of the few places where pie still feels like a real everyday food rather than a special occasion performance. On Saturdays it’s the busiest, and that’s usually when the freshest selection is on display and when people are most likely to leave with a box in hand instead of just one slice.
What Wanda’s does well is the old bakery basics, and I mean that as a compliment. The fruit pies are the main event, especially when the fruit is in season and doesn’t need any help. If you catch peach-blueberry in August, get it. If there’s sour cherry, also get it. Apple in the fall, strawberry-rhubarb in late spring, whatever is fresh and available at the peak of its season — that’s where the bakery makes the strongest case for itself. The crust is the kind you want in a proper pie: buttery, tender, and substantial enough to hold up without turning into a dry cracker at the edge. The filling isn’t trying to overwhelm you with sugar. It tastes like fruit first, which sounds obvious until you realize how many pie shops miss that part. Wanda’s understands that a pie should be more than sweet; it should have brightness, structure, and a little bit of generosity.
The butter tarts are another reason people keep coming back. Ontario butter tarts can be very divisive in the best way, because everyone has a strong opinion about how runny the filling should be, whether raisins belong there, and whether pecans improve things or just get in the way. Wanda’s keeps it honest. A good butter tart should be set enough to hold together, but still have that soft, gooey middle that gives the whole thing its character. Too firm and you lose the point. Too loose and you’re basically eating sugar soup in a pastry shell. Wanda’s usually lands in the sweet spot. The plain ones are the best place to start because they let you taste the pastry and the filling without distraction. If you like raisins, go for it; if you don’t, you’re not missing anything essential. A butter tart shouldn’t need accessories to justify itself, and this is the sort of place that seems to understand that instinctively.
The daily square case is worth checking too, because it tells you a lot about a bakery’s rhythm. Some days it’s date square, some days lemon square, sometimes Nanaimo bar, sometimes something with almonds or another small old-school comfort dessert that feels exactly right with coffee. The point isn’t novelty. It’s the fact that they’re baking what they know how to bake well, and they’re doing it in a way that fits the day’s production rather than a social media calendar. I always respect a bakery that knows its own limits and strengths. Date squares especially make sense here: chewy, oaty, a little sticky, not pretending to be elegant, just satisfying in that straightforward Canadian way. If you’re the sort of person who likes a dessert that can stand on a napkin and still feel like a complete event, you’ll be happy.
The atmosphere at Wanda’s is friendly but not fussy. Staff are usually moving quickly, especially when the line builds, but they’re generally practical and down to earth. You won’t get a big theatrical explanation of each pie, and honestly that’s part of the charm. The place doesn’t need to sell itself with a script. People come in, point at the case, ask what’s fresh, and leave with boxes. There’s a rhythm to it that feels very Toronto in the best sense: efficient, unpretentious, slightly hurried, but still warm. You’ll see all kinds of customers. Some are clearly regulars who know exactly what they want and don’t need to look at the menu for more than a second. Some are Kensington visitors who’ve wandered in because they wanted a snack and wound up leaving with enough baked goods to cover the next two days. Some are buying for a dinner, a family gathering, or because someone at home requested a butter tart and nothing else will do.
Kensington Market is the right setting for this kind of bakery because the neighbourhood has always rewarded places that feel lived-in rather than staged. It’s a walking neighbourhood, full of people popping between shops, fruit stands, cafés, vintage stores, and small food counters, so Wanda’s fits naturally into the day’s routine. It’s not the sort of place you drive to for a single transaction and then disappear. It works better as part of a larger loop: grab a pie, wander the market, sit somewhere with coffee, maybe come back later if something else in the case looks too good to pass up. That said, Kensington also means foot traffic, weekend crowds, and the occasional line that moves slower than you’d like if you’re in a rush. If you’re coming on a Saturday, especially mid-morning, expect company. The smart move is to go early if you want the fullest selection and the shortest wait, or go later in the day if you’re less concerned about the exact flavour and just want a solid dessert without the peak-time bustle.
What sets Wanda’s apart from a lot of competitors is that it doesn’t seem interested in competing on spectacle. Toronto has plenty of bakeries now that are excellent at laminated dough, glossy entremets, and highly styled pastries that photograph beautifully and disappear in one bite. Wanda’s is on the other end of the spectrum, and that’s not a downgrade. It’s a place where the basics are the point: actual fruit, proper pastry, reliable tarts, and sweets that feel like they were designed to be eaten rather than posted. The prices help too. In a city where dessert can get absurdly expensive fast, Wanda’s still feels like a bakery where you can buy a couple of things without doing math in your head. That matters. It changes how you order. It changes how often you come back. It makes it easier to take a chance on an extra slice or a square because you’re not paying boutique-level markup for the privilege.
For a visitor, the best strategy is simple. Don’t overthink it, and don’t treat Wanda’s like a one-item stop unless you have to. Get a slice or a whole pie if you’re taking something home. If you’re there with a friend, split a fruit pie and a butter tart so you can compare styles. If it’s summer and there’s peach-blueberry, that’s the one I’d prioritize without hesitation. If there’s sour cherry, I’d strongly consider it too because those pies can be one of the best arguments for seasonal baking in the city. If you’re only looking for a quick sugar fix, a butter tart and a square will do just fine. If you want to see what the bakery does best, ask what’s fresh and what just came out that day. The answer matters here more than a fixed list of “signature” items.
The honest reality is that Wanda’s can get busy enough to feel slightly chaotic, especially on weekends and around lunch. You might wait a bit. You might find that one flavour you wanted has already sold out. You might have to settle for a different fruit pie than the one you had in your head. None of that is a problem if you come in with the right expectations. That’s part of what makes it feel like a real bakery instead of a curated dessert counter. The good stuff goes, and that’s fine. If you want the widest selection, show up earlier in the day. If you want the calmest experience, weekday mornings are your friend. If you want the most life in the shop, Saturday is the day, but be prepared to share the room with everyone else who also knows the pies are worth it.
There’s something satisfying about a place like Wanda’s surviving on competence, consistency, and good taste rather than reinvention. It gives Kensington a dessert stop that feels local in the truest sense: not local because it’s quaint, but because people actually use it. They buy pies for dinner, butter tarts for the office, squares for an afternoon coffee, and whole desserts for birthdays and visiting relatives. That everyday usefulness is a kind of luxury all its own. If you want one Toronto bakery that captures the practical side of the city’s sweet tooth — the part that values a proper crust, a seasonal filling, and a fair price as much as it values charm — Wanda’s Pie in the Sky is exactly the right stop.
A butter tart is a small open-faced pastry tart with a filling of butter, brown sugar, eggs, and syrup — baked until the edges are set and the center is slightly gooey. It's one of Canada's most iconic baked goods, with roots in Ontario's baking tradition. Variations include raisins, pecans, or maple syrup.
The filling consistency — set on the edges but slightly runny in the center — is the defining quality factor. The pastry shell should be flaky and golden, not thick and dense. A great butter tart is sweet but not cloying, with a clean buttery finish.
Strawberry-rhubarb in late May-June, sour cherry in July-August, peach in August-September, apple from September through November. A good bakery sources seasonal fruit at peak ripeness, so the pie reflects the time of year honestly.
A Nanaimo bar is a no-bake Canadian confection with three layers: a wafer-coconut-cocoa crumb base, a custard-flavoured buttercream center, and a dark chocolate top. Named for Nanaimo, BC, it appears at every Canadian bakery and potluck. Quality varies widely — the custard layer should be smooth and not too sweet.
WTF Toronto creates guides using independent editorial research, official sources, local knowledge and firsthand experience where available. Commercial relationships are disclosed where applicable.